School is back for 2021, and some students will get extra help this year. Students in Victoria and New South Wales (NSW) who fell behind in their learning during the COVID-19 lockdowns of 2020 will be eligible for a tutoring programme.
Governments have invested more than half a billion dollars in our two biggest states to help kids bounce back. Data released late last year showed after almost two months of learning from home, NSW students had fallen, on average, three to four months behind in year 3 reading, and two to three months behind in year 5 reading and numeracy. Year 9 students were up to four months behind in numeracy.
Disadvantaged students are likely to have been hardest hit. A Grattan Institute report estimated the achievement gap between disadvantaged students and the rest widens three times more quickly during remote schooling.
Here’s what we know about these new tutoring schemes.
Evidence shows good tutoring programmes can work
A lot of money has been invested in the new schemes: 250 million Australian dollars in Victoria and AU$337 million in NSW. They will be rolled out in both primary and secondary schools, and are expected to reach about 200,000 students in Victoria and 290,000 in NSW.
The new programmes should be worth it. Evidence from the UK and US suggests a good tutoring programme can provide students with around four months of additional learning over one to two school terms.
And they can help to close the pre-existing achievement gap for disadvantaged students, which is much greater than the gap caused from the losses during COVID-19 disruptions. In Australia, disadvantaged students from families where parents’ education is low are, on average, about three years behind their more privileged peers by Year 9.
How the new schemes will work
All government schools — and a small number of non-government schools — have been given funding for tutoring, with more money going to disadvantaged schools with many students from low socioeconomic backgrounds.
About one in five students — targeted to those who need it most — will get tutoring.
Small groups of up to five students will work with tutors each week at school. Schools will determine whether sessions are run either in or outside of class time, and in NSW we understand there is a possibility of after-school sessions as well.
If parents have concerns about their child either missing out or not wanting to participate, they should discuss this with their school.
How to get the most out of the tutoring programme
For Swiss preschoolers, democracy is child’s play. https://t.co/1tApJ7x5ry
— Study International (@Study_INTNL) January 23, 2021
Teachers will need to accurately identify which students have been struggling and why. They will need to make judgements using a range of assessments, including student tests, classroom observations or student interviews.
Even though teachers make these assessments every day in regular teaching, it is hard to do well. Some teachers will need extra support to do this, such as guidance from expert teachers or assessment specialists. It is a key step to get right.
Next, rigorous selection of tutors, and good training for them, will be key.
Close working relationships between tutors and teachers will help ensure students get the support they need.
And perhaps most importantly, the quality of the teaching by the teacher and tutor will be critical. Teachers are likely to be swamped this year, and education departments should provide extra support to help teachers guide tutors as needed.
Programmes include well-specified training, materials and teaching approaches. For literacy, for example, these programmes can provide extra support on proven ways of teaching oral language skills or certain aspects of reading.
Education departments will need to keep an eye on the quality of candidates coming forward for tutoring roles, given a big workforce is being recruited fast with tight constraints on who can apply. If the pool of tutor candidates needs to be made bigger, evidence shows university graduates from a range of fields, not just education, can be good tutors too.
Schools will also need to take care to ensure students do not feel stigma about being identified for tutoring. Teachers will need to pay attention to student confidence, and avoid negative messaging or separating students on an ongoing basis, which can have negative impacts (also known as streaming).
Parents can explain to their child that extra tutoring support will help them catch up and feel more confident at school.
Tutoring programme are an opportunity for governments to learn
— Study International (@Study_INTNL) January 22, 2021
The NSW and Victorian governments have taken on a mammoth task. Almost 10,000 tutors will be mobilised at short notice. And there are still many aspects of the tutoring programme design where the evidence is not clear, such as around the exact nature of tutoring training.
It will not be a failure if some of the programmes don’t work well. But it will be a problem if we don’t learn why.
Australia now has an opportunity to trial a promising initiative and to understand how it can work best. The tutoring schemes of the 2021 school year should be rigorously evaluated. Where possible, education departments should also run small-scale trials which test different tutoring approaches.
South Australia has also announced a small ($3.6 million) maths tutoring programme, which provides a good opportunity for teachers to compare the tuition approaches in different states.